Anti-Terrorism LawsuitStill Fighting for 9/11 Families & SurvivorsMotley Rice fights for justice, even in difficult and unusual circumstances. This is the story of a 20-year quest to deliver redress for families of 9/11 victims and survivors. Active casePrimary Contact Jodi Westbrook Flowers Robert T. Haefele Anti-Terrorism Lawsuit Attorneys Michael E. Elsner John M. Eubanks Jade A. Haileselassie Donald A. Migliori Ronald L. Motley Tammy Cauley Rivers Elizabeth Smith Mitchell B. ThorntonShareFacebookTwitterLinkedIn
Sept. 11, 2001: The Road to JusticeThe world watched in horror after American Airlines Flight 11 crashed into the North Tower of the World Trade Center at 8:46 a.m., Sept. 11, 2001. A second plane, United Airlines Flight 175, crashed into the World Trade Center’s South Tower minutes later at 9:03 a.m. American Airlines Flight 77 later crashed into the Pentagon’s western façade at 9:37 a.m. After a delay in takeoff, passengers and crew aboard United Airlines Flight 93 learned of the attacks in New York and Washington, D.C. and fought back against hijackers on the plane, forcing their attackers to crash into a field in Pennsylvania before it could reach its intended target.Nearly 3,000 people lost their lives in the attacks, making the tragedy the deadliest terrorist attack ever on U.S. soil. Nineteen hijackers with weapons carried out the attacks and used the planes as missiles in a plan to destroy targets in New York City and Washington D.C.Survivors and family members of the deceased desperately sought answers and accountability in the tragedy’s wake, and their fight for justice continues to this day. Over the past 20 years they have captured the world’s attention and shone a light on terrorism, enacting laws to hold the supporters of terrorism accountable and sever their financial pipeline.After the attacks, Motley Rice attorneys led and continue to lead the charge to develop groundbreaking complex litigation against the financiers and material supporters of the terrorist organization al Qaeda.Motley Rice also launched a worldwide, private discovery effort to uncover the alleged negligence of airlines, security companies and airports in connection with the attacks. At the request of victims’ families and survivors of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, our attorneys initiated legal action against airlines and security companies in In re September 11 Litigation, representing 56 of the 96 families that opted out of the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund in hopes of gaining greater answers, accountability and recourse through consolidated actions against the airlines and security companies responsible for the hijacked planes used in the 9/11 attacks. Our work led our investigators and attorneys to dozens of countries, and an astonishing collection of documents were recovered showing what we believed to be clear knowledge by the carriers and others of their security shortcomings regarding terrorist threats. The resulting settlements shattered a settlement matrix developed and utilized for decades.In keeping with late Motley Rice co-founder Ron Motley’s “no stone left unturned” discovery philosophy, Motley Rice lawyers are prosecuting the case under the Anti-Terrorism Act (ATA) for September 11 families and survivors demanding accountability for material support provided to al Qaeda.In a case with more than 7,000 docket filings, it would be impossible to identify all the legal milestones. Here are some of the key events that unfolded over the past 20 years on their road to justice: 2002 Bankrupting TerrorismAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 15, 2002Flanked by September 11 family members during a press conference on Aug. 15, 2002, Motley Rice co-founder Ron Motley announces the filing of groundbreaking litigation against the financiers and material supporters of the terrorist organization al Qaeda.Related LinksWatch Press Conference on C-Span Bankrupting TerrorismAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 15, 2002Related LinksWatch Press Conference on C-Span 2002 September 11 Families & Survivors take actionAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 15, 2002Press Release: September 11 Families Take Groundbreaking Action to Expose Terrorist Financing Schemes, Cut Off Money Pipeline.Related LinksRead the Press Release September 11 Families & Survivors take actionAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 15, 2002Related LinksRead the Press Release 2002 Bavis v. United Airlines Corporation et al.Aviation Litigation September 9, 2002The family of United Flight 175 passenger Mark Bavis files Bavis v. United Airlines Corporation et al. on Sept. 9, 2002, alleging the defendants were liable for airport security checkpoint failures, poor training, faulty cockpit doors and failure by the airline industry to acknowledge and adequately respond to government warnings about terrorist threats. Bavis v. United Airlines Corporation et al.Aviation Litigation September 9, 2002 2002 The Spanish documentsAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 20, 2002In September 2002, Motley Rice releases major new findings by the firm’s investigative team that were exclusively obtained from the government of Spain and link members of the Saudi royal family to money laundering efforts that support terrorists. The firm’s efforts are later furthered by an Order from Judge Robertson for the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia requesting the Spanish authorities provide all of the underlying data contained in their indictments of the Spanish-Saudi al Qaeda money laundering schemes. The Spanish documentsAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 20, 2002 2002 The criminal trial of Mounir el-Motassadeq in GermanyAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 2002Motley Rice intervenes in the criminal trial of Mounir el-Motassadeq in Germany and later receives approximately 45,000 pages of material that were considered for introduction in the German trial. The criminal trial of Mounir el-Motassadeq in GermanyAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 2002 2002 New documents from Spanish-Saudi money laundering schemesAnti-Terrorism Litigation October 11, 2002Motley Rice moves for and is granted an order by the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia that requests that the Spanish authorities provide all underlying data contained in their indictments of Spanish-Saudi money laundering schemes. The firm receives approximately 37,000 pages of documents, as well as surveillance video prepared by Ghasoub Al-Abrash Ghalyoun, one of the members of the Spanish al Qaeda cell. Motley Rice was able to share key pieces of evidence with the German prosecutors and our own government. New documents from Spanish-Saudi money laundering schemesAnti-Terrorism Litigation October 11, 2002 2002 The 9/11 Families United to Bankrupt Terrorism open letter to President BushLegislation November 1, 2002Met with resistance at the outset of their fight for justice, the 9/11 Families United to Bankrupt Terrorism pen an open letter to President Bush seeking support.Related LinksRead the letter to President Bush The 9/11 Families United to Bankrupt Terrorism open letter to President BushLegislation November 1, 2002Related LinksRead the letter to President Bush 2002 The Bosnian documentsAnti-Terrorism Litigation Late 2002Motley Rice travels to Bosnia several times in 2002 to request documents that were seized in a series of FBI raids of Bosnian charities. The firm meets with members of the Supreme Court of Bosnia Herzegovina in October, prompting three Orders from the Court directing the U.S. government to return the 'Bosnian' documents that were seized, and to provide a copy of the materials to the 9/11 Families United to Bankrupt Terrorism for use in the civil action. The Bosnian documentsAnti-Terrorism Litigation Late 2002 2002 Litigating Terror – Tobacco Lawyer Takes on Saudis in a Sept. 11 SuitAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 12, 2002On Dec. 12, 2002, The Wall Street Journal features Ron Motley in its article, “Litigating Terror – Tobacco Lawyer Takes on Saudis in a Sept. 11 Suit.”Related LinksRead more from The Wall Street Journal Litigating Terror – Tobacco Lawyer Takes on Saudis in a Sept. 11 SuitAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 12, 2002Related LinksRead more from The Wall Street Journal 2003 September 11 family members and survivors provide statements at al Qaeda co-conspirator Mounir Motassadeq’s trialAnti-Terrorism Litigation January 30, 2003September 11 family members and survivors represented by Motley Rice make victim impact statements before the German Court in the criminal trial of al Qaeda co-conspirator Mounir Motassadeq ahead of his conviction. September 11 family members and survivors provide statements at al Qaeda co-conspirator Mounir Motassadeq’s trialAnti-Terrorism Litigation January 30, 2003 2003 The “Golden Chain”Anti-Terrorism Litigation March 2003In March 2003, the U.S. prosecutor in Chicago sends 750,000 pages of the seized Bosnian documents to Motley Rice, including the critical “Golden Chain” document that lists the major financial contributors to the formation of al Qaeda and minutes describing the formation of al Qaeda, its pledge, and membership requirements, marketing strategy and much more. The “Golden Chain”Anti-Terrorism Litigation March 2003 2003 September 11 Families letter to U.S. SenateLegislation May 12, 2003September 11 Families to U.S. Senate: Don’t Disarm Us in the War on Terrorism!Related DocumentsRead the Letter to the Senate September 11 Families letter to U.S. SenateLegislation May 12, 2003Related DocumentsRead the Letter to the Senate 2003 Special Report: The King of Torts vs. al-Qaida Inc.Anti-Terrorism Litigation June 23, 2003On June 23, 2003, The Post and Courier features the Motley Rice legal team for the September 11 families and survivors in its article, “Special Report: The King of Torts vs. al-Qaida Inc.”Related LinksRead the Post & Courier article Special Report: The King of Torts vs. al-Qaida Inc.Anti-Terrorism Litigation June 23, 2003Related LinksRead the Post & Courier article 2004 Can a trial lawyer expose Saudi complicity in terrorism?Anti-Terrorism Litigation March 14, 2004“Can a trial lawyer expose Saudi complicity in terrorism?” The New York Times Magazine features Motley Rice co-founder Ron Motley on March 14, 2004. Related DocumentsRead more from The New York Times Magazine Can a trial lawyer expose Saudi complicity in terrorism?Anti-Terrorism Litigation March 14, 2004Related DocumentsRead more from The New York Times Magazine 2004 Spanish wiretaps and financial transactionsAnti-Terrorism Litigation Early 2004Spain provides documents containing information on wiretaps and financial transfers of money directly to the 9/11 hijackers in the United States, as well as evidence of operational planning meetings in Spain as late as June of 2001. Spanish wiretaps and financial transactionsAnti-Terrorism Litigation Early 2004 2004 9/11 files show warnings were urgent and persistentAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 18, 2004As federal investigations into the 9/11 attacks intensify, The New York Times publishes its article, “9/11 Files Show Warnings Were Urgent and Persistent,” on April 18, 2004.Related LinksRead the New York Times article 9/11 files show warnings were urgent and persistentAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 18, 2004Related LinksRead the New York Times article 2004 The 9/11 Commission ReportAnti-Terrorism Litigation July 22, 2004On July 22, 2004, the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States, also known as the 9/11 Commission, releases its official findings on the events that led up to the terrorist attacks. Former New Jersey Governor Thomas Kean chaired the bipartisan Commission and oversaw the review of millions of pages in documents, and interviews involving more than 1,200 across several countries during the nearly 2-year investigation.Related LinksRead the 9/11 Commission Report The 9/11 Commission ReportAnti-Terrorism Litigation July 22, 2004Related LinksRead the 9/11 Commission Report 2004 The Niaz Khan InterviewAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 4, 2004Motley Rice attorney for the September 11 families and survivors Michael Elsner interviews Niaz Khan. A citizen of the U.K., born in Pakistan, Khan asserts he defected from al Qaeda in 2000 and warned the FBI of impending plans to attack U.S. civilians.Related LinksWatch a portion of the interview The Niaz Khan InterviewAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 4, 2004Related LinksWatch a portion of the interview 2005 Judge Richard Conway Casey rules on a motion to dismissAnti-Terrorism Litigation January 18, 2005U.S. District Judge Richard Conway Casey rules on a motion to dismiss the 9/11 litigation.Related LinksRead more on this ruling Judge Richard Conway Casey rules on a motion to dismissAnti-Terrorism Litigation January 18, 2005Related LinksRead more on this ruling 2005 Spanish court receives 9/11 commission reportAnti-Terrorism Litigation Early 2005In 2005, Motley Rice continues to cooperate with the Spanish criminal prosecution of al Qaeda by Judge Baltasar Garzon, including providing the Spanish Court with a certified copy of the 9/11 Commission & Joint Congressional Intelligence Committee Findings. Spanish court receives 9/11 commission reportAnti-Terrorism Litigation Early 2005 2005 Database uncovers links terrorists work to concealAnti-Terrorism Litigation June 5, 2005On June 5, 2005, The Post and Courier reports on Motley Rice’s growing trove of records detailing the scope of the attacks and the financial backing of global terrorism in its article, “Database uncovers links terrorists work to conceal.”Related DocumentsRead more from The Post and Courier Database uncovers links terrorists work to concealAnti-Terrorism Litigation June 5, 2005Related DocumentsRead more from The Post and Courier 2006 The prosecution of al Qaeda member Zacarias MoussaouiAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 7, 2006Ron Motley argues for the release of key documents April 7, 2006 during a hearing regarding the prosecution of al Qaeda member Zacarias Moussaoui.Related LinksRead more from CBS News The prosecution of al Qaeda member Zacarias MoussaouiAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 7, 2006Related LinksRead more from CBS News 2006 Dulles International Airport security footageAviation Litigation July 31, 2006Video submitted into evidence on July 31, 2006 shows five hijackers going through security at Dulles International Airport Gov’t Ex. NT00211 in U.S. v. Zacarias Moussaoui.Related LinksWatch the Security Footage Dulles International Airport security footageAviation Litigation July 31, 2006Related LinksWatch the Security Footage 2007 Settlements do not deter September 11 plaintiffs seeking trialsAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 19, 2007Fourteen settlements are announced in September 2007 for some survivors and families of the September 11 victims, while others maintain their desire to see their case through to trial. The settling families and survivors “had reached a point where they were satisfied that the mix of their motivations — from compensation to accountability, to answers — was satisfied,” Motley Rice attorney Don Migliori tells The New York Times in the article, “Settlements Do Not Deter 9/11 Plaintiffs Seeking Trials.”Related LinksRead more from the New York Times Settlements do not deter September 11 plaintiffs seeking trialsAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 19, 2007Related LinksRead more from the New York Times 2009 September 11 families and survivors respond to U.S. administration's support of Saudi royal familyAnti-Terrorism Litigation May 29, 2009Several family members of 9/11 victims have issued a statement on behalf of the 9/11 Families United to Bankrupt Terrorism in response to the Solicitor General's refusal to support the September 11 families' Petition for Writ of Certiorari with the U.S. Supreme Court. On Friday, May 29, the Justice Department filed a brief with the high court supporting the Saudi royal family's argument of sovereign immunity from the 9/11 terrorist financing lawsuit.Related DocumentsRead the full statement September 11 families and survivors respond to U.S. administration's support of Saudi royal familyAnti-Terrorism Litigation May 29, 2009Related DocumentsRead the full statement 2009 JASTA introduced in the SenateLegislation December 23, 2009Senators Arlen Specter (D-PA), Charles Schumer (D-NY) and Lindsey Graham (R-SC) introduce the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act (JASTA) on Dec. 23, 2009. The bill seeks, in part, to amend federal judicial code to remove prohibitions that barred civil actions in U.S. courts against foreign states with regards to terrorist acts committed against U.S. citizens.Related LinksRead more about this legislation JASTA introduced in the SenateLegislation December 23, 2009Related LinksRead more about this legislation 2009 U.S. Embassy cables from Secretary of State Hillary ClintonAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 30, 2009In U.S. embassy cables dated Dec. 30, 2009, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton states “Saudi Arabia constitute the most significant source of funding to Sunni terrorist groups worldwide. … Saudi Arabia remains a critical financial support base for al-Qa’ida, the Taliban, LeT, and other terrorist groups… ”Related LinksRead the full document U.S. Embassy cables from Secretary of State Hillary ClintonAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 30, 2009Related LinksRead the full document 2011 New ruling in Bavis v. United Airlines Corporation et al.Aviation Litigation September 7, 2011On Sept. 7, 2011, the Judge overseeing Bavis v. United Airlines Corporation et al. rules that United Airlines and Huntleigh USA have to prove "only that they adhered to federal aviation safety standards, and didn't have to meet the state standards of wrongful death that the plaintiffs had sought." The defendants later file a motion for summary judgment seeking dismissal of the case. In response, the Bavis family files a 100-page response with 127 exhibits, giving an outline of what the family intends to present at trial to prove the alleged negligence on the part of United and Huntleigh. New ruling in Bavis v. United Airlines Corporation et al.Aviation Litigation September 7, 2011 2011 9/11 aviation security: Final wrongful death lawsuit reaches resolutionAviation Litigation September 17, 2011On Sept. 19, 2011, the Bavis family reaches an agreement with United Airlines and Huntleigh USA, bringing to an end nearly a decade of wrongful death litigation in connection with the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, Bavis v. United Airlines Corporation et al.Related LinksRead more from ABC News 9/11 aviation security: Final wrongful death lawsuit reaches resolutionAviation Litigation September 17, 2011Related LinksRead more from ABC News 2011 List of JASTA co-sponsors continues to growLegislation December 12, 2011In a letter dated Dec. 12, 2011, the 9/11 Families United to Bankrupt Terrorism express their gratitude to the growing number of co-sponsors of the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act (JASTA) S.1894: U.S. Senators John Cornyn (R-TX), Lindsey Graham (R-SC), Orrin Hatch (R-UT), Jon Kyl (R-AZ), Charles Schumer (D-NY), and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI).Related LinksRead the Letters List of JASTA co-sponsors continues to growLegislation December 12, 2011Related LinksRead the Letters 2012 Former senators go on recordAnti-Terrorism Litigation February 29, 2012On Feb. 29, 2012, The New York Times publishes its article, “Saudi Arabia May Be Tied to 9/11, 2 Ex-Senators Say.”Related LinksRead more from the New York Times Former senators go on recordAnti-Terrorism Litigation February 29, 2012Related LinksRead more from the New York Times 2012 September 11 widow and former senator interviewed about alleged Saudi connectionAnti-Terrorism Litigation March 20, 2012U.S. Sen. Bob Graham (D-FL) joins September 11 widow Terry Strada on MSNBC’s Andrea Mitchell Reports to discuss their continued demands that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia be brought to justice.Related LinksRead more about this interview September 11 widow and former senator interviewed about alleged Saudi connectionAnti-Terrorism Litigation March 20, 2012Related LinksRead more about this interview 2013 Ronald L. Motley (1944-2013) August 22, 2013Eleven years after leading the charge for September 11 families and survivors, Ron Motley sadly passes away on Aug. 22, 2013 at the age of 68. Motley Rice reaffirms its commitment to carry forward in his memory. View More +Related LinksMemoriam of Ronald L. Motley Ronald L. Motley (1944-2013) August 22, 2013"Ron was a true giant of the legal profession. A trail blazer and innovator. A charismatic master of the courtroom. A tenacious interrogator. The greatest trial lawyer ever. All marked by unmatched courage in going after any wrongdoer, no matter how big and powerful, and by his bottomless well of compassion for those who had been wronged."Related LinksMemoriam of Ronald L. Motley 2013 Second Circuit reverses decision that had dismissed claimsAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 19, 2013On Dec. 19, 2013, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reverses an earlier decision that had dismissed claims against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the Saudi High Commission.Related LinksRead more about this decisionRead more from ABC News Second Circuit reverses decision that had dismissed claimsAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 19, 2013Related LinksRead more about this decisionRead more from ABC News 2014 9/11 Families letter to President ObamaAnti-Terrorism Litigation June 24, 2014On June 24, 2014, the 9/11 Families United For Justice Against Terrorism pen a letter to President Obama demanding the release of 28 redacted pages that were withheld from the Joint Inquiry into Intelligence Activities Before and After the Terrorist Attacks of September 2001. In 2002, at the time of the report’s release, then President George W. Bush, said the pages would “damage American intelligence operations, revealing ‘sources and methods that would make it harder for us to win the war on terror.’”Related LinksRead the full letter 9/11 Families letter to President ObamaAnti-Terrorism Litigation June 24, 2014Related LinksRead the full letter 2014 SCOTUS declines to hear defense’s appealAnti-Terrorism Litigation June 30, 2014On June 30, 2014 the U.S. Supreme Court declines to hear a defense appeal of the litigation, allowing claims to move forward against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Related LinksRead more from The Philadelphia Inquirer SCOTUS declines to hear defense’s appealAnti-Terrorism Litigation June 30, 2014Related LinksRead more from The Philadelphia Inquirer 2014 The Foreseeability TimelineAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 11, 2014Motley Rice donates a 77-page “Foreseeability Timeline” to the National September 11 Memorial & Museum in New York City, outlining events over several decades that should have alerted authorities to the possibility of an imminent attack.Related DocumentsRead the Foreseeability Timeline The Foreseeability TimelineAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 11, 2014Related DocumentsRead the Foreseeability Timeline 2014 Did terrorist Zacarias Moussaoui meet with a Saudi prince and princess?Anti-Terrorism Litigation November 17, 2014In November 2014, terrorist Zacarias Moussaoui alleges that he previously met with a Saudi prince and princess who provided funding in support of the 9/11 hijackers.Related LinksRead more from CNN Did terrorist Zacarias Moussaoui meet with a Saudi prince and princess?Anti-Terrorism Litigation November 17, 2014Related LinksRead more from CNN 2014 Senate report personal to September 11 Families & SurvivorsAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 11, 2014September 11 widow Terry Strada appears on CNN to discuss the release of a controversial report detailing “enhanced interrogation” methods used by the CIA against suspected terrorists.Related LinksWatch the CNN interview Senate report personal to September 11 Families & SurvivorsAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 11, 2014Related LinksWatch the CNN interview 2015 Pressure to release the 28 Pages increasesAnti-Terrorism Litigation February 5, 2015Calls increase for the release of the 28 redacted pages that were withheld from the Joint Inquiry into Intelligence Activities Before and After the Terrorist Attacks of September 2001. Related LinksRead more from CNN Pressure to release the 28 Pages increasesAnti-Terrorism Litigation February 5, 2015Related LinksRead more from CNN 2016 Calls to pass JASTA intensifyLegislation July 14, 2016The House Committee on the Judiciary holds a hearing on July 14, 2016 as calls for the passing of the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act intensify.Related LinksRead this hearing transcript Calls to pass JASTA intensifyLegislation July 14, 2016Related LinksRead this hearing transcript 2016 28 Pages finally brought to lightAnti-Terrorism Litigation July 15, 2016The U.S. government releases the missing 28 pages from the Joint Inquiry into Intelligence Activities Before and After the Terrorist Attacks of September 2001 report on July 15, 2016, roughly 14 years after the documents were first hidden in a vault under the Capitol.Related LinksRead the 28 Pages 28 Pages finally brought to lightAnti-Terrorism Litigation July 15, 2016Related LinksRead the 28 Pages 2016 JASTA becomes lawLegislation September 28, 2016On Sept. 28, 2016, the U.S. Senate and the U.S. House of Representatives vote to override a presidential veto of JASTA, following President Obama’s veto of the bill on Friday, Sept. 23, 2016. In overriding the veto and clearing the way for the law, Congress ensures that foreign sponsors of terrorist attacks in the U.S. can be held accountable in U.S. civil courts, abolishing foreign governments’ immunity for their role in supporting terror attacks on U.S. soil.Related LinksRead more about JASTA JASTA becomes lawLegislation September 28, 2016Related LinksRead more about JASTA 2017 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is brought back into the lawsuitAnti-Terrorism Litigation March 17, 2017The September 11 victims, survivors and families file an amended complaint adding the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia as a defendant in the civil litigation.Related LinksRead the amended complaint The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is brought back into the lawsuitAnti-Terrorism Litigation March 17, 2017Related LinksRead the amended complaint 2017 9/11 Never Forget Mobile Exhibit travels to Mt. Pleasant SC September 8, 2017Motley Rice sponsors the 9/11 Never Forget Mobile Exhibit in Mt. Pleasant, S.C.Related LinksLearn more about the mobile exhibit 9/11 Never Forget Mobile Exhibit travels to Mt. Pleasant SC September 8, 2017Related LinksLearn more about the mobile exhibit 2018 Federal Judge: 9/11 litigation against Saudi Arabia may proceedAnti-Terrorism Litigation March 28, 2018Litigation filed by the September 11 families and survivors overcomes a motion to dismiss from the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia on March 28, 2018. The federal judge overseeing the case finds that plaintiffs’ allegations met required standards for the case to move forward under the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act (JASTA). In addition to denying the defense’s motion, U.S. District Judge George Daniels for the Southern District of New York also grants a plaintiffs’ request seeking to conduct targeted jurisdictional discovery.Related LinksRead more about this filingRead more from Reuters Federal Judge: 9/11 litigation against Saudi Arabia may proceedAnti-Terrorism Litigation March 28, 2018Related LinksRead more about this filingRead more from Reuters 2018 Judge declines to seal Saudi documentsAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 27, 2018On Aug. 27, 2018, U.S. Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn declines to seal more than 6,000 pages in documents produced by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.Related LinksRead the order Judge declines to seal Saudi documentsAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 27, 2018Related LinksRead the order 2019 The Terrorism FilesAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 10, 2019The Post and Courier publishes “The Terrorism Files: 18 years after 9/11, an SC man’s lawsuit against foreign government kicks into high gear,” featuring Motley Rice attorney Robert Haefele on Sept. 10, 2019.Related LinksRead more from The Post and Courier The Terrorism FilesAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 10, 2019Related LinksRead more from The Post and Courier 2019 DOJ declassifies additional documentsAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 12, 2019On Sept. 12, 2019, the Department of Justice files a document explaining, “In light of the exceptional nature of this case, the FBI has determined to exercise its discretion, pursuant to section 3.1 (d) of Executive Order 13526, to declassify the name of the third main subject in the public interest and to release that name to counsel for the parties under the FBI Protective Order.” However, it added that “[t]he remaining information that has been redacted from the 2012 Summary Report remains classified and/or privileged and protected from disclosure.” DOJ declassifies additional documentsAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 12, 2019 2020 Saudi officials to sit for depositionsAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 27, 2020U.S. Magistrate Judge Sarah Netburn issues an order requiring Saudi officials to sit for depositions.Related LinksRead the order Saudi officials to sit for depositionsAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 27, 2020Related LinksRead the order 2020 New pleadings filed against the Republic of SudanAnti-Terrorism Litigation November 20, 2020The PEC file supplemental pleadings against The Republic of Sudan, adding allegations to the original lawsuit.Related DocumentsRead the amended complaint New pleadings filed against the Republic of SudanAnti-Terrorism Litigation November 20, 2020Related DocumentsRead the amended complaint 2020 Court sets deadline for depositions of the Saudi fact witnessesAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 1, 2020The Court sets a June 30, 2021 deadline for completion of depositions of the Saudi fact witnesses and, in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, parameters on how the parties could conduct depositions. Court sets deadline for depositions of the Saudi fact witnessesAnti-Terrorism Litigation December 1, 2020 2021 President Biden signs order for review and declassification of documents September 3, 2021The Executive Order requires a declassification review of documents from the U.S. governments’ investigation into the 9/11 attacks, sets a process for that review, and creates oversight and accountability reporting obligations for the “justification for each decision not to declassify information."Related LinksRead more about this order President Biden signs order for review and declassification of documents September 3, 2021Related LinksRead more about this order 2021 Looking Forward September 11, 2021On behalf of plaintiffs, Motley Rice continues to press for transparency, accountability and a trial on the merits. Depositions of Saudi fact witnesses were conducted in earnest and completed June 30, 2021 in preparation for an eventual trial. Plaintiffs disclosed experts they intend to use in the case against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia on Aug. 4, 2021. As of Sept. 11, 2021, plaintiffs have conducted depositions of 18 fact witnesses with firsthand knowledge of the attacks for claims against Saudi Arabia. Ten defense experts and six experts for plaintiffs also testified regarding claims against charities. View More + Looking Forward September 11, 2021The 9/11 families and survivors continue to push for the release of key documents that have been kept hidden but are believed to detail the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s alleged role in the attacks. Joined by several family members of 9/11 victims, Sens. Bob Menendez and Richard Blumenthal introduced legislation on Aug. 5 seeking the release of thousands of documents that are believed to hold long-hidden details regarding the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s alleged role in supporting the terrorist attacks. The announcement came weeks ahead of the 20th memorial of the worst terrorist attack on American soil. President Biden signed an Executive Order roughly a month after the legislation was introduced, to require a declassification review process of documents. We will watch closely in coming months as the process commences.Watch the press conference held by the 9/11 families, survivors and Sens. Menendez and Blumenthal.Learn more on how 9/11 families, survivors and others can get involved in the ongoing push for justice and transparency. 2022 Additional documents are produced to plaintiffs by the U. S. governmentAnti-Terrorism Litigation Early 2022The FBI produced additional documents identifying Omar Al Bayoumi as an agent of the Saudi General Intelligence Presidency. They are released pursuant to Executive Order 14040. The documents also shed additional light on the Saudi government’s affiliations in the U.S.Related LinksRead the documents Additional documents are produced to plaintiffs by the U. S. governmentAnti-Terrorism Litigation Early 2022Related LinksRead the documents 2022 Expert Report exchangeAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 1, 2022Plaintiffs exchange expert reports with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Expert Report exchangeAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 1, 2022 2023 Dubai Islamic Bank: Court grants motion for summary judgmentAnti-Terrorism Litigation March 9, 2023The Court grants Dubai Islamic Bank’s motion for summary judgment, finding that the Court lacked personal jurisdiction over the bank. Dubai Islamic Bank: Court grants motion for summary judgmentAnti-Terrorism Litigation March 9, 2023 2023 Court limits plaintiffs’ scope of discoveryAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 17, 2023The Court denies a plaintiff request that sought authorization to resolve a discovery issue on appeal. The discovery issue stemmed from a March 28, 2018, order that limited plaintiffs’ discovery to inquiries surrounding Omar Al Bayoumi, Fahad Al Thumairy, and their support network. Plaintiffs have fought to expand this discovery to other theories of Saudi Arabia’s involvement in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001. Court limits plaintiffs’ scope of discoveryAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 17, 2023 2023 The Republic of Sudan moves to dismissAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 19, 2023The Republic of Sudan moves to dismiss claims against it over material support for Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda. The Court denied the motion. The Republic of Sudan moves to dismissAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 19, 2023 2023 Daubert Ruling: Court restricts defense testimonyAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 27, 2023Plaintiffs successfully petition the Court to strike testimony from defense expert Ambassador Chas Freeman. Additionally, the Court limits portions of testimony from three other defense expert witnesses – Jonathan Benthall, Jonathan Marks and John Sidel. Daubert Ruling: Court restricts defense testimonyAnti-Terrorism Litigation April 27, 2023 2023 Ensuring Justice for Victims of Terrorism Act (EJVTA) IntroducedLegislation June/July 2023EJVTA is introduced in the Senate as S. 2082 on June 21, 2023 by Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) and in the House as H.R. 4951 on July 26, 2023 by Rep. Jefferson Van Drew (R-NJ). This legislation focuses on correcting JASTA by clarifying certain provisions of the original legislation to permit aiding and abetting liability under the Antiterrorism Act against foreign sovereigns where the Court holds jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. 1605B, and ensures that judgments against foreign sovereigns pursuant to the exception to immunity at 1605B can be executed under 28 U.S.C. 1610. Ensuring Justice for Victims of Terrorism Act (EJVTA) IntroducedLegislation June/July 2023 2023 Motion deniedAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 10, 2023The Court denies the Republic of Sudan’s motion to dismiss the case, allowing claims to proceed against the country. The Republic of Sudan later appeals this decision. Motion deniedAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 10, 2023 2023 Saudi Arabia files third motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdictionAnti-Terrorism Litigation October 6, 2023Saudi Arabia files a third motion to dismiss the case. Extensive briefing is then undertaken over the course of many months. Saudi Arabia files third motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdictionAnti-Terrorism Litigation October 6, 2023 2024 American Victims of Terrorism Compensation Act introducedLegislation May 16, 2024AVTCA: Congressman Mike Lawler (R-NY), as well as Reps. Nicole Malliotakis (NY-11), Josh Gottheimer (D-NJ), and Dan Goldman (D-NY) introduce the American Victims of Terror Compensation Act. This bipartisan legislation seeks to provide guaranteed funding sources for the U.S. Victims of State Sponsored Terrorism (USVSST) Fund following multiple years where the Fund did not make distributions due to insufficient funds available to justify payments to eligible claimants. American Victims of Terrorism Compensation Act introducedLegislation May 16, 2024 2024 Al-Bayoumi “casing” video featured on CBS News June 20, 2024CBS News publishes an article featuring a “casing” videotape of the U.S. Capital building prior to the 9/11 attacks by Omar Al-Bayoumi. The FBI has identified Al-Bayoumi as a Saudi intelligence agent who was known to have “provided substantial assistance” to the hijackers. In the video, Al-Bayoumi notes entrances and exits of the U.S. Capital in addition to security posts and a model of the building. The video was originally seized by British police in the days following 9/11. Al-Bayoumi “casing” video featured on CBS News June 20, 2024 2024 Plaintiffs argue latest motion to dismiss by Saudi ArabiaAnti-Terrorism Litigation July 31, 2024The Court hears arguments regarding Saudi Arabia’s latest attempt to have the case dismissed. Plaintiffs’ counsel argued that significant new evidence shows Bayoumi worked as an undercover agent of Saudi Arabia's "militant extremist network" known as the Ministry of Islamic Affairs. The Court reserved decision on the motion. Plaintiffs argue latest motion to dismiss by Saudi ArabiaAnti-Terrorism Litigation July 31, 2024 2024 Sudan appeal deniedAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 4, 2024The Second Circuit Court of Appeals denied Sudan’s challenge to the district court’s ruling that the country was not immune to liability for providing material support to al Qaeda prior to the September 11th terrorist attacks. The September 11th families hope to move forward with discovery. Sudan appeal deniedAnti-Terrorism Litigation September 4, 2024 2025 Saudi Arabia’s motion deniedAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 28, 2025U.S. District Court Judge George Daniels denied Saudi Arabia’s motion to dismiss rejecting Saudi Arabia’s argument that the exception to its sovereign immunity, provided by the Justice Against State Sponsors of Terrorism Act, does not apply and finding the undisputed facts allow the Court to maintain jurisdiction of the proceedings as plaintiffs’ claims advance to trial.Related LinksFederal Judge denies Saudi Arabia Motion to Dismiss in 9/11 families lawsuit Saudi Arabia’s motion deniedAnti-Terrorism Litigation August 28, 2025Related LinksFederal Judge denies Saudi Arabia Motion to Dismiss in 9/11 families lawsuit